3 Reasons Why X-Men (2000) Got It Right and Why the MCU is Screwed! | X-Men (2000) Explained
Why will the MCU struggle to beat the original X-Men (2000)? Three scenes from Bryan Singer's film reveal something Marvel needs to get right about mutants, prejudice and what makes the X-Men special. In this X-Men movie breakdown, I explore the train station moment where two children encounter Cyclops, the surprisingly meaningful scene involving Tommy and a jellyfish, and Magneto's unforgettable introduction during the Holocaust. Together, these scenes show how prejudice is learned, how fe...
Why will the MCU struggle to beat the original X-Men (2000)? Three scenes from Bryan Singer's film reveal something Marvel needs to get right about mutants, prejudice and what makes the X-Men special.
In this X-Men movie breakdown, I explore the train station moment where two children encounter Cyclops, the surprisingly meaningful scene involving Tommy and a jellyfish, and Magneto's unforgettable introduction during the Holocaust.
Together, these scenes show how prejudice is learned, how fear can become cruelty, and why Magneto remains one of Marvel's most compelling villains. With Adam Driver joining the MCU's X-Men as Mister Sinister, could Marvel overlook the social conflict that made the original so memorable?
Subscribe to Fandom Portals for weekly character and movie breakdowns exploring what our favourite stories can teach us.
CHAPTERS
00:00 Why the MCU Must Learn From X-Men (2000)
01:02 Scene 1: Cyclops and How Prejudice Is Learned
03:32 Scene 2: The Jellyfish, Senator Kelly and Compassion
05:59 Scene 3: Magneto's Unforgettable Origin
08:15 The MCU's Mister Sinister Problem
09:27 Why Prejudice Is the Real Villain of X-Men
QUESTION OF THE WEEK
Can the MCU make a better X-Men movie than the original from 2000? What does Marvel need to get right?
ORIGINAL FILM REFERENCE
X-Men (2000)
Director: Bryan Singer
Screenplay: David Hayter
Original studio: 20th Century Fox
Featured cast: Ian McKellen (Magneto), James Marsden (Cyclops), Patrick Stewart (Professor X), Hugh Jackman (Wolverine) and Bruce Davison (Senator Kelly).
Original film material is referenced for criticism, commentary and analysis. Rights in the original film remain with the respective copyright holders.
#XMen #Magneto #Marvel
Contact Us:
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@FandomPortals
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/aaron_fandomportals/?locale=en
Email: fandomportals@gmail.com
X-Men Sets The Standard
SPEAKER_00Brian Singer nailed X-Men in the 2000s. That's the kind of storytelling that Marvel has to match if they want their X-Men movie to succeed. And three scenes from the original prove that Brian Singer understood that better than the MCU ever will. And the third one is the reason fans still argue about whether Magneto was right more than 25 years after this film came out. I'm Aaron and I explore our favorite films to help us become better versions of ourselves. The original X-Men isn't perfect by any means. The action has aged and there's plenty of exposition and those costumes aren't great either.
SPEAKER_02What would you prefer? Yellow spandex?
SPEAKER_00But Brahinsinger understood what makes these characters so special. He understood that prejudice operates at every level of society. People learn it at train stations, parents disguise it as protection, and the fear spreads everywhere. Three scenes prove that understanding. And I bet that they're not the scenes that you would expect.
Fear Learned At The Train Station
SPEAKER_00So let's start at a train station. Nope, not that part.
unknownScream for me.
SPEAKER_00Not that part either. I'm talking about two boys noticing Cyclops wearing his red visors.
SPEAKER_03Come along, I told you.
SPEAKER_00In seconds, Singer shows us how prejudice can be learned. The boys see someone exciting. Their mother sees someone that they need to avoid. Scott hasn't threatened anyone here, he's just smiled at two kids. As a dad, this reminds me of taking my kids to the park. They make friends in about three seconds, and without knowing names, birth dates, or backgrounds, they're playing together effortlessly while I'm still standing there deciding whether to introduce myself to the other dad or not. Children can be really accepting of difference, and our responses as parents can influence whether that behavior continues as they grow. I see it every day at school as well. For all the rubbish you hear about middle schoolers and the internet generation, I've watched kids these days include others so different from themselves and also comfort others in need and show some empathy too. So what does Singer capture here? Those boys weren't frightened of Cyclops, but their mother was. And if she keeps acting like that, her reaction could teach them to be too. Now here's something I love. According to the production team, the boy in that scene was genuinely excited to see James Marsden dressed as Cyclops, Me Too Kid. And his smile happens spontaneously. But Singer recognized this opportunity and added the mother's reaction in to further explain the point of mutant fear being culturally
Prejudice Without Open Hatred
SPEAKER_00learned. And I think that decision shows exactly what Singer's understanding of the X-Men truly is, because prejudice doesn't always begin with hatred. Sometimes it's taught by people that we trust, and sometimes it's taught on accident or through the habits that we don't mean to perpetuate. Now, this mum obviously loves her kids and obviously wants to protect them too, but she doesn't know how damaging her ignorance could actually be. With just a few seconds in the middle of a busy action set piece, Singer takes a moment to show the audience just why mutants have such a hard time. And that shows depth of knowledge that I hope the MCU rock with as well. But the next scene explores the contrast to that, and it's only a few seconds
Jellyfish Scene Mirrors Weapon X
SPEAKER_00long. So Tommy is on a beach, he's poking a jellyfish with a stick while his sister begs him to stop it.
SPEAKER_04Tommy, let it go. Tommy, please let it go. I'm telling mommy.
SPEAKER_00And I reckon Tommy represents one of the most dangerous attitudes towards things we don't understand. He's found something different, and rather than respecting it or even leaving it alone, he's experimenting with it. Now, at this moment, I think about Wolverine and Weapon X. Scientists treated Logan's body as something that they could poke and prod and weaponize as well. His suffering here becomes secondary to what they could gain from their experiments, and Tommy's behavior reflects the same thing. But his sister represents another side of humanity. She doesn't understand the jellyfish any better than Tommy does. She just knows that hurting it's wrong. But singer takes this one step further because immediately after that, Senator Kelly walks his way out of the ocean, his new fishy, pale, gill-ridden body on display for all the beach goers to see. At this moment, Kelly's frightened, he's vulnerable, and he's lost control over his body, just like the jellyfish, just like Wolverine, just like many mutants discovering their powers for the first time. Now seeing his placement here is deliberate. Kelly supported mutant registration and used public fear to justify controlling others, and now Magneto has taken away Kelly's freedom. As a teacher, I've seen how effective learning through experience can be, but Kelly's only starting to understand mutant suffering when the negatives impact him. Tommy's sister didn't need that experience to show compassion. And Magneto hasn't taught Kelly empathy at all. He's forced suffering upon him. And I picked up this scene while I recorded my X-Men reaction video. So if you want to see my initial response to this, then check out the video. It'll be on this channel on the end card. So you can watch it after finishing this one. Because Singer uses Tommy and his sister as a subtle way to show that humans can be cruel to mutants, they can also be kind. And he does it without having to shove hours worth of social studies exposition down our throats as well. He does it with a jellyfish and a stick. And the MCU has to get the mutant-human relationship right for their X-Men to feel real and genuine. But even so, it's this last scene that I'm about to talk about that convinces me without a doubt that the MCU has an enormous challenge ahead of them.
Magneto Origin And Moral Split
SPEAKER_00The grayscale imagery, oppressive camera angles, and deliberate screams and desperation from the extras create this awful feeling of powerlessness. And in the middle of it is a young Eric Lenscher. He has these extraordinary abilities, but no control over his own life. We desperately want him to escape here. Before we even meet Magneto the villain, Singer shows us Eric the survivor. And we're completely sympathetic towards him, of course, and that's brilliant storytelling because years later, when Eric hears politicians discussing mutant registration, he recognizes something frighteningly similar. He's witnessed what happens when governments turn prejudice and fear into persecution. And we all understand why he doesn't trust humanity, but understanding his fear doesn't excuse his actions. Eric believes that humanity must be forced to change, and because we've experienced Eric's trauma here, we're emotionally invested in their disagreement. We sympathize with Magneto, even when he's wrong. Some fans still believe Magneto was right. I still see that hashtag floating around the internet now. Heck, I even believed it until I re-watched this in my later years, but here we are. More than 25 years after the film's release, and that argument continues. And that's why I believe this is one of the greatest villain introductions ever. Stinger has made us understand a man whose experiences of persecution have led him to persecute others. And that's the political conflict the MCU needs to get right. But I don't think they will. And here's why.
Why The MCU Could Miss It
SPEAKER_00Stinger has always described the X-Men movies as a political story about difference and tolerance. And these three scenes show that perfectly. So the MCU has a problem now because Marvel casts Adam Driver as Nathaniel Milberry. For those who don't know, that's the alias for Mr. Sinister. Now, I love that casting and I love Adam Driver, but if the story centers on a mutant fighting one evil scientist experimenting on their DNA, then Marvel misses the point entirely because when the villain is an evil geneticist, the audience gets an easy out here. They can say, that doesn't represent me. The problem is just that one guy. It's not all of us. And Singer? Well, he never gave anyone that kind of escape. He made us sit with the uncomfortable idea that we aren't being kind to mutants, and the system we use to keep us safe has let them down. Prejudice in X-Men exists in ordinary families. The mother on the train station, scientific institutions as well, Weapon X, government policies, Senator Kelly. The X-Men are heroic because they're literally fighting against everyone to do the right thing. Magneto shows how persecution creates more hatred. The train station scene shows how fear gets taught, and Tommy and the Jellyfish show how curiosity without compassion can turn to cruelty. The real problem runs deeper than one villain here. It's an entire society who struggles to accept difference. And that's really the real villain of X-Men. And you can't defeat that by punching it in the face. The MCU could explore this same issue through Mr. Sinister, but bigger fights, more mutants, and better costumes won't automatically make a better X-Men movie. The original challenges are how we respond to people who are different from us. And that's why this original X-Men movie remains the best X-Men movie. And the MCU will struggle to beat what Brian Singers achieved back in the 2000s.
The Real Villain And Next Steps
SPEAKER_00If you've enjoyed this breakdown of scenes that prove the MCU will struggle to make an X-Men film that beats the original, then check out my video on why Xavier and Magneto responds so differently to humanity's fear. The breakdown is right over here, guys. And let me know can the MCU beat the original X-Men movie? Let me know in the comments below. And of course, don't forget to subscribe, guys, for more character lessons from our favorite films. I'm Aaron, keep learning, keep going, and keep loving fandoms. I'll see you all through the next portal.
RSS Feed